Keplers law of planetary motion and the habitable zone where there is a consistant envirnment are sufficient to
rule out
Sitchen's 12th planet theory.
[My bolding]
“Rule out” Sitchin’s theory is a bit too harsh, I would imagine. It is quite possible that other planets exist in our solar system. OK, the Nibiru story is a great deal fantasy, but what if it is true? By the time it makes its next visit, we all have gone from this life…
MockingGods Philosophical Prodigy
Joined: Nov 14, 2002
Posts: 4039
Location: USA
Posted:
Wed Nov 05, 2008 7:42 am
Quote:
It is quite possible that other planets exist in our solar system.
Depending on how you wish to define "planet", yes. However, any new planet-like objects would almost certainly not have the capacity to maintain living organisms, at least as we know them.
Cygnus Graduate Thinker
Joined: Mar 26, 2008
Posts: 549
Posted:
Wed Nov 05, 2008 9:24 am
Quote:
It is quite possible that other planets exist in our solar system.
Ya don't say!
_________________ "Buddha says: "Do not flatter thy benefactor!" Let one repeat this saying in a Christian church: it immediately purifies the air of all Christianity."
-Friedrich Nietzsche
zacherystaylor Confident Learner
Joined: Jul 07, 2008
Posts: 71
Posted:
Wed Nov 05, 2008 2:49 pm
[quote="Julio"]
zacherystaylor wrote:
Julio wrote:
Keplers law of planetary motion and the habitable zone where there is a consistant envirnment are sufficient to
rule out
Sitchen's 12th planet theory.
[My bolding]
“Rule out” Sitchin’s theory is a bit too harsh, I would imagine. It is quite possible that other planets exist in our solar system. OK, the Nibiru story is a great deal fantasy, but what if it is true? By the time it makes its next visit, we all have gone from this life…
Yes it is possible that other planets are in our solar system in fact it wasn't that long ago that they changed the definition to add 3 planets making a total of 12 planets with more pending. 2 weeks later they changed it again knocking the 3 new planets plus Pluto back off making it 8 planets.
However none of these planets were in the habitable zone. None of them had a chance at microscopic life let alone advanced intelligent life.
_________________ If you don't teach children to think rationally when they are young they might get a mental illness called religion.
There are no Good Gods only Good Dogs.
http://www.geocities.com/zacherystaylor/culttactics.htm
Julio Intern
Joined: Feb 21, 2006
Posts: 231
Posted:
Wed Nov 05, 2008 4:36 pm
[quote="zacherystaylor"]
Julio wrote:
zacherystaylor wrote:
Julio wrote:
Keplers law of planetary motion and the habitable zone where there is a consistant envirnment are sufficient to
rule out
Sitchen's 12th planet theory.
[My bolding]
“Rule out” Sitchin’s theory is a bit too harsh, I would imagine. It is quite possible that other planets exist in our solar system. OK, the Nibiru story is a great deal fantasy, but what if it is true? By the time it makes its next visit, we all have gone from this life…
Yes it is possible that other planets are in our solar system in fact it wasn't that long ago that they changed the definition to add 3 planets making a total of 12 planets with more pending. 2 weeks later they changed it again knocking the 3 new planets plus Pluto back off making it 8 planets.
However none of these planets were in the habitable zone. None of them had a chance at microscopic life let alone advanced intelligent life.
But let’s say it is a fascinating subject.
I once read somewhere that there is a paralleled earth located 180 degrees from ours, in the same plane or so.
Surely, that is nonsense, because telescopes and the like would have by now found it.
And yet, do we already know everything about bacteria?
Imagine that the Annunaki bodies could withstand harsh environments.
On the other hand, Sitchin is not altogether an amateur in these matters, is he?
MockingGods Philosophical Prodigy
Joined: Nov 14, 2002
Posts: 4039
Location: USA
Posted:
Thu Nov 06, 2008 6:52 am
Quote:
And yet, do we already know everything about bacteria?
It's possible we may find single cellular life on Mars, probably extinct though. There's also a great deal of excitement about exploring certain moons of the gas giants for simple life forms.
zacherystaylor Confident Learner
Joined: Jul 07, 2008
Posts: 71
Posted:
Thu Nov 06, 2008 3:24 pm
[quote="Julio"]
zacherystaylor wrote:
Julio wrote:
zacherystaylor wrote:
Julio wrote:
Keplers law of planetary motion and the habitable zone where there is a consistant envirnment are sufficient to
rule out
Sitchen's 12th planet theory.
[My bolding]
“Rule out” Sitchin’s theory is a bit too harsh, I would imagine. It is quite possible that other planets exist in our solar system. OK, the Nibiru story is a great deal fantasy, but what if it is true? By the time it makes its next visit, we all have gone from this life…
Yes it is possible that other planets are in our solar system in fact it wasn't that long ago that they changed the definition to add 3 planets making a total of 12 planets with more pending. 2 weeks later they changed it again knocking the 3 new planets plus Pluto back off making it 8 planets.
However none of these planets were in the habitable zone. None of them had a chance at microscopic life let alone advanced intelligent life.
But let’s say it is a fascinating subject.
I once read somewhere that there is a paralleled earth located 180 degrees from ours, in the same plane or so.
Surely, that is nonsense, because telescopes and the like would have by now found it.
And yet, do we already know everything about bacteria?
Imagine that the Annunaki bodies could withstand harsh environments.
On the other hand, Sitchin is not altogether an amateur in these matters, is he?
One of the "contactees" claimed he was contacted by aliens from "Clarion" behind the sun techecially it might be possible but it is incredibly unlikely. It would have to be the same exact distance from the sun as earth or it would travel at a different speed in order to maintain orbit. If it is there which I seriously doubt NASA would have found it and they would have to be covering it up.
If Sitchen is good at anything I wouldn't know I didn't get very far before I gave up. There are more credible sources that I would rather read.
_________________ If you don't teach children to think rationally when they are young they might get a mental illness called religion.
There are no Good Gods only Good Dogs.
http://www.geocities.com/zacherystaylor/culttactics.htm
Julio Intern
Joined: Feb 21, 2006
Posts: 231
Posted:
Thu Nov 06, 2008 3:25 pm
MockingGods wrote:
Quote:
And yet, do we already know everything about bacteria?
It's possible we may find single cellular life on Mars, probably extinct though. There's also a great deal of excitement about exploring certain moons of the gas giants for simple life forms.
Great!
One way or another we’ll find a way out to escape this tormented planet.
We NEED to!
Here in Africa, three thousand children die daily from Malaria alone.
Never mind AIDS and all the rest.
This is a cursed planet, we lament.
Julio Intern
Joined: Feb 21, 2006
Posts: 231
Posted:
Thu Nov 06, 2008 3:58 pm
I read five of Sitchin’s books.
At first, they are a bit too monotonous, but if you like the subject, eventually you read the whole story.
Half of his content is fiction and imagination, of course.
However, he being a Jew, believes there is enough evidence of [a] God.
The mysterious creation is for him the main reason for God’s existence. He never denied the existence of a Creator.
View next topic View previous topic
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
* You can syndicate our news and blog using the file